Baseball card story from Anthony Manahan

Infielder Anthony Manahan played in the Mariners and Phillies organizations from 1990 to 1996, hitting .276 in 600 minor league games. Now an insurance professional in Arizona, he kindly shared with me this baseball card story.

"I have a fresh card story. I was with an old teammate last week named Rich Amaral. Rich told me that I am actually pictured on the back of one of his cards as him.  I need to find that card."

Thanks! Here is the card, from 1996 Collector's Choice.

Here is the front - as you can see, Amaral and Manahan don't look too similar.

Finally, here is an actual card of Manahan.
Thanks!