In the comments of the last post, Night Owl mentioned that Roy Carlson just did a deep dive on this set for Sports Collectors Daily. Carlson has been posting a lot of very interesting articles lately about the images in vintage Topps sets. Turns out the drawing of Menke here is based on the image later seen on his 1971 Topps coin.
Last time it was an 8-0 shutout for Topps. Will Hostess get on the board this time?
The Hostess card has Doyle at Shea Stadium, with a dark blue sky behind him. I would guess this is a printing issue rather than the photo being taken near sunset. Meanwhile, Topps has a close-up of Doyle appearing to be following through on a swing, with the shadow of the batting cage on him. It would appear he is next to the cage, not in it.
Denny Doyle was a typical 1970s middle-infielder. He was a good, though not elite defender. He was an OK hitter with a little power, not an automatic out but not much of a threat. In 944 games between 1970 and 1977 with the Phillies, Angels and Red Sox, he hit .250 with 113 2B, 16 HR, 237 RBI and 38 SB. In 1978 he founded Doyle Baseball Camps, one of the earliest and most successful youth instruction organizations. He died in 2022.
Last time 1987 cruised to an 8-2 win. Will it win again here?
Bobby Tiefenauer was ten years removed from his major league debut when this card was issued, but he was still officially a rookie. He was a knuckleballer who excelled at AAA but struggled in the majors. He pitched in six games for the Cardinals in 1952, and another 18 games in 1955. He had brief cups of coffee with the Indians in 1960 and the Cardinals in 1961, and was sold to the expansion Colt .45's before their inaugural 1962 season. If you look closely you can see the STL logo airbrushed over in blue on his cap. As a 32-year-old rookie in 1962 he went 2-4 with a 4.34 ERA in 43 games. He was then traded back to the Cardinals, who sold him to the Braves. He had his best seasons with the Braves in 1963 and 1964, going 5-7 with 15 saves and a 2.40 ERA in 58 games. He struggled in 1965, and was traded to the Yankees, appearing in 10 games for them before being traded to the Indians. In 25 games for three teams in '65 he went 1-6 with 6 saves and a 4.22 ERA. He ended his career with brief stints with the '67 Indians and '68 Cubs. Overall in 179 games, all in relief, he went 9-25 with 23 saves and a 3.84 ERA. After his playing career he was a coach in the Phillies organization. He died of cancer in 2000.
Jamie Moyer looks pensive as he gets his rookie card photo taken at Shea Stadium. This was the first of a long line of cards for Moyer. In his 20s Moyer was a mediocre starting pitcher for the Cubs, Rangers and Cardinals, and seemed washed up at age 29, spending all of 1992 in the minors. However he came back to have his first really good season in 1993 with the Orioles, going 12-9 with a 3.43 ERA. However, he didn't really become a star until he was traded to the Mariners in 1996. In 11 seasons with Seattle, Moyer went 145-87 with a 3.97 ERA, twice winning 20 games in a season. Moyer struggled to start the 2006 season and the Mariners traded the 43-year-old Moyer to the Phillies for two minor leaguers. With Philadelphia Moyer had yet another comeback, and in 2008 he went 16-7 and won his only World Series ring at the age of 45. Moyer was injured in 2011 and missed the whole season, but came back for 10 games with the Rockies in 2012 at the age of 49. Overall in 696 games he went 269-209 with a 4.25 ERA. He is the all-time leader in home runs allowed with 522, a product of a long career, early struggles and the high-HR environment of his later years.
I got a lot of nine 1971 Dell Today stamps from eBay (actually it was 3 lots of 3). I don't have many from this set, and they look very nice.
One thing that attracted me to these stamps but kept the price low is that they were laminated. In my mind this improves the stamps, as it makes them thicker, more substantial like cards.
Here they are in groups of three - my groupings, not the lots they were broken up in.
Starting off with three solid hitters - Horton, Carty and Alex Johnson.
Weird to see someone else wearing Dwight Gooden's #16.
Here's a group of long-gone furriers with visible signs on this building at 26th Street and 7th Avenue. It appears they date to 1923 - 101 years ago!
Thanks to Walter Grutchfield's terrific site, here are the furriers listed.
The top row is barely visible now, but Saretsky Raw Furs opened in 1908 and was at this address until 1923. The business closed with owner Victor Saretsky's death in 1976.
The next one is also hard to read, but it was for Samuel Kahn Furs and Skins. Started in 1917, the business was at this address from 1923 to 1925. The business lasted into the 1950s.
The next two are easier to read. Brucker & Biderman had a partnership from 1923 to 1927, before they went their separate ways to other furriers.
As Grutchfield puts it, "The Durable Fur Co. was not durable." It appears it was only in business for a short time in 1923.
Under the SmartWater ad is another ad for Schuman Bros., which lasted until 1970.
One from OBC this week. Chris Kodl knocked out nine of my 1979 Hostess needs.
The back: While Winfield's multi-sport skills were well known (taken in the MLB, NFL, NBA and ABA drafts), it is forgotten that he was also a terrific pitcher. Perhaps in another era he could have been a Shohei Ohtani type.
The player: Dave Winfield was one of the all-time greats. He was a five-tool player who excelled at every part of the game. He was certainly one of my favorite players when I started following baseball and the Yankees. Looking back, some of his struggles may have been pressure to justify his big contract. Still, he had great success everywhere he played, finally winning a World Series with Toronto in 1992. In 2,973 games over 22 seasons, he hit .283 with 465 HR, 1,833 RBI and 223 SB. He was a 12-time All-Star and 7-time Gold Glove winner.
The man: Winfield has been heavily involved in charitable and business adventures going back to his days with the Padres, and has always had a wide variety of interests beyond sports. He started charitable work in his rookie season, and in 1977 the David M. Winfield Foundation was the first charitable foundation founded by an active athlete. In addition to his numerous charitable adventures, he has numerous business interests. In addition to his own company, Winfield is an Advisor to the MLBPA, investor in a fitness startup, and is on the board of directors of a publicly-traded SPAC.
My collection: I have 224 of his cards, from 1974 to 1996. There are still a lot more cards from his Yankees days that I would be interested in trading for, including:
1982 Drakes #31
1983 Fleer Star Stickers #39
1983 Kellogg's #15
1984 Nestle #6
1985 Yankees Police #4
1986 Burger King #2
1987 Action Superstars #10
1987 Classic #11
1987 Drake's #5
1987 Indiana Blue Sox #4
1987 Kay-Bee #33
1988 Baseball Stars Series 2 #5
1988 Donruss Baseball's Best #244
1988 Drake's #12
1988 Fleer MVPs #43
1988 Fleer Mini #44
1988 Gray Series 1 #4
1988 Yankees Unlicensed #4
1988 New York New York #4
1988 Pacific #2
1988 Red Stars Series 2 #5
1988 Score Box Bottoms #8
1988 Sportflics Gamewinners #7
1989 Classic #32
1989 Fleer All-Stars #44
1989 Pacific #4
1989 Topps Box Bottoms #P
1989 Topps UK #84
1989 Kay-Bee #32
1990 Sportflics #87
1990 Hills #17
1990 Topps TV #34
The player, in brief: Originally a Yankees prospect, Geronimo was a Rule V selection by the Astros in 1969. After three years in Houston with little playing time, he was a throw-in in the trade that sent Joe Morgan to the Reds. Though never a star like Morgan, Geronimo developed into an integral part of the Big Red Machine. The center fielder won four straight Gold Gloves from 1974 to 1977. In his best years he hit for some average with doubles power and a little speed. His production tailed off significantly when he turned 30 in 1978. He ended his career with three seasons as a backup outfielder in KC. Overall in 1,522 games he hit .258 with 161 doubles, 51 HR, 392 RBI and 82 SB.
Post-playing career, in brief: He has been involved in many coaching and development endeavors in his native Dominican Republic. He is now retired.
My collection: I have 29 of his cards, from 1971 to 1984. I would be interested in trading for 1975 Hostess #121.
I always liked his nickname: The Singer Throwing Machine.
Last time Hostess held on for a 6-4 victory. Who will win here?
Mike Ivie takes some cuts for the photographer at Candlestick Park. I believe that is the Giants' #12 Gary Thomason in the background on the Hostess card. Some large ads for Chevron gas and Olympia beer are visible in in the background.
Ivie was the first overall pick of the 1970 draft, but his major league career failed to live up to expectation. This was partly due to emotional and mental issues that Ivie opened up about later in his career. Overall, in 857 games for four teams over 11 seasons, he hit .269 with 81 HR and 411 RBI. Ivie originally came up as a catcher, but developed a mental block about throwing the ball back to the pitcher and was moved to first baseman. After the 1979 season, when Ivie seemed to finally be putting it all together, (.286, 27 HR, 89 RBI), Ivie badly cut his hand with a hunting knife. The Sporting News Guide said, "The sensitive first baseman couldn't cope with the long rehabilitation process, and the injury also affected his brittle confidence." Ivie, who kept a low public profile after his playing career, died in 2023.
Last time 1962 eked out a 5-4 win. What will happen this time?
This is one of the more unusual rookie cards in the vintage Topps set. He came up with the White Sox for five games in 1957, and in 1958 Topps issued a card with this photo (wearing a White Sox cap) against a yellow background. In 1958 he pitched in 7 more games for the pale hose, and his 1959 card reused his 1958 photo, now on a gray background. Though Rudolph pitched for both the White Sox and Reds in 1959, he did not get a card in 1960. He spent the next couple of years in the minors, and was a Rule V selection by the Indians in November of 1961. Topps decided this warranted a card, so they airbrushed a Cleveland cap on the photo they had already used twice, put him on an orange background, and declared him a 1962 rookie. He pitched in one game for the Tribe before they traded him to the Senators in May. With Washington he finally got a chance to stick in the majors for good, with 102 appearances (57 starts) between 1962 and 1964. Finally an established major leaguer, Topps finally issued cards with new photos of Rudolph in '63 and '64. Overall in 124 games, Rudolph went 18-32 with an ERA of 4.00. He was best known for being married to burlesque star Patti Waggin. Rudolph managed her, with her appearances usually coinciding with Rudolph's baseball travel. They had a daughter in 1961. Rudolph retired from baseball in 1966 and started a contracting company, but was killed in 1968 when his truck overturned.
Wayne Tolleson at shortstop at Yankee Stadium. This was my first year following baseball, and the scrappy, spectacled little guy was easy for a little kid to root for. Tolleson was a two-sport star at Western Carolina, where he was an All-Southern-Conference WR. He came up with the Rangers in 1981 and was a utility infielder for them through 1985. He was traded to the White Sox in 1986, who in mid-season dealt him to the Yankees. He stayed with the Yankees through 1989. Tolleson was a good fielder with excellent speed, but could not hit for average or power. In 863 games he hit .241 with 9 HR, 133 RBI and 108 SB. After his playing career he was an executive for Centerplate, a food vendor at sports stadiums. He is now a consultant and coach for youth baseball organizations.
