Kicking off the 1985 Tigers set showdown. Which card is better - the one Topps used for the base set, or the Wendy's/Coca-Cola Tigers set?
These photos look like they were taken at the same time, from two opposite directions. Spring training photos of a very serious looking Sparky Anderson. The Coke card has some coaches visible, while the Topps card has the stands.Sparky Anderson had won two World Series with the Big Red Machine, and in 1984 he sealed his Hall of Fame case by leading a much less star-studded Tigers team to a World Championship. The Tigers went off to a 35-5 start, and despite cooling off considerably were still easily the best team in a weak American League that season. In the ALCS they made quick work of the Royals (who would have finished 6th if they played in the AL East), and in the World Series they knocked off the Padres, who surprised the favored Cubs in the NLCS. Sparky kept the Tigers competitive for several more seasons, but they slid into mediocrity under his watch, as he ended his career with five sub-.500 seasons out of seven before retiring after the 1995 season. Anderson, who played in one major league season, for the Phillies in 1959, was involved in various charitable endeavors after he retired. He died in 2010.

Wow, it really comes down to the small details on this one! I'm voting for burgers since the "D" logo shows up on his jacket.
ReplyDeleteburgers
ReplyDeleteBurgers. Love the food logos.
ReplyDeleteI have the 1981 Coke set but I didn't really know this one! I think I'll agree with Matt--the little details like the logo and the coaches in the background give it to burgers in a close one.
ReplyDeleteAfter burgers maybe do some Kellogg's? Or even something like the 1954 Red Hart dog food (against Topps...or Bowman? Or both?)
Burgers. As much as I enjoy the 1985 Topps flagship design, this Wendy's/Coca-Cola oddball issue is nicer. It's going to take a really nice action shot or interesting photo for "gum" to win. But even if we're not factoring the card's design into the competition... I like Sparky's "burger" photo better.
ReplyDeleteBurgers.
ReplyDeleteI’d prefer to not see the Coaches in the background, but the Coke & Wendy’s logos outweigh that distraction.
I’ll give the dissenting view of Gum, I think the coaches are distracting
ReplyDelete