First baseman
Vito Chiaravalloti played in the Blue Jays organization from 2003 to 2006, winning the New York-Penn League triple crown in 2003. Now a social studies teacher and baseball coach at
Christian Brothers Academy in New Jersey, he kindly shared with me some baseball card stories. Some of the stories refer to mentions of him in an
interview I did last year with photographer Mike Janes.
"Great interview with Mike, but I'd like to maybe make it more
accurate if you don't mind. First off, I feel bad if he thinks I wasn't
thrilled about the "Three bat" card that he took. I know I wasn't
smiling, but I love that card and I probably was just going through a
"don't smile and look tough in pictures" phase. lol.
Second, I did not sit the last game of the season that year to win
the triple crown. I insisted on playing because I did not want it to
appear as if I was ducking the game or afraid of losing the batting
title. I bargained with my manager, and we reached a compromise that I
would get 2 at bats. I hit a double in my first ab, which guaranteed me
the batting title no matter what Nyjer Morgan did in his game (who I
think did sit his final game, but not sure). Anyway, just wanted that
to be accurate because I made a point of not sitting that game.
As for baseball cards...great questions. I have so many stories
about cards, since I collected them avidly growing up. There was
nothing cooler than when I saw my first official Topps card (which
ironically Mike took the shot for). That is a moment I will never
forget, because as most ball players will tell you, they always dreamed
of having their own baseball card. But the story that sticks out most
in my mind is so bizarre it almost seems made up. It was either late
spring training or early season 2004 and a box of cards showed up that I
needed to sign. When I opened the box, I realized I was not the only
player on the card. It was a dual player card and I literally couldn't
believe that the other player was my college teammate Tim Stauffer! I
think it was a 2004 Bowman. I then thought they made the connection
that we both went to the University of Richmond, and that's why they put
us together. But there was NO mention of Richmond on the card, so it
seemed to be just a crazy coincidence. I took a picture and texted Tim
right away (not sure if I could have texted him the picture because this
was 04, but I may have emailed it to him). We had a good laugh about
it, and I told him that he would be signing them next. That moment has
always stuck out in my mind. Tim has now gone on to have a successful
big league career, so unfortunately I am bringing down the value of that
card.
I'm not sure if I have a favorite card of my own. Of course the
Stauffer/Bowman card with me on it is a unique one. But If I had to
pick, I would say between the Cracker Jack card and the 04 Topps Chrome
just because they are both different. You would probably get a better
answer from my buddy Matt Titko, though, who is an avid card/memorabilia
collector. Matt has collected every card that I ever had, even ones I
never knew existed! And he insisted on buying them all! I was always
like, "Matt, I can probably get you these cards, you don't have to buy
them." I'll ask Matt and see which one he likes the best.
My favorite card all-time though would have to be the 1987 Topps
Gary Carter card, for so many reasons. First, I was a huge Mets fan and
Gary Carter was my favorite player/idol. I collected every single one
of his cards and he was probably one of the single greatest influences
on why I wanted to be a professional baseball player. But the 87 card
sticks out to me because it brings me back to a moment in my life. With
the "wooden" frame, those cards are so distinct and recognizable, and
any kid who grew up in the 80's and knows cards always talks about that
one. When I see an 87 Topps, especially the Carter card, I'm
immediately thrown back in time. It's like I'm 7 years old again,
organizing all my cards in my basement at my parents house - it just
takes me back to a place and time in my life. Plus, it's one of the
first cards I ever collected, so it will always have a fond place in my
memory. On a side note, in my last season of playing professionally I
got to meet my hero. I was playing in the Atlantic League and Gary was
managing for the Long Island Ducks. We wound up building a great
relationship that year, and although I never made it to the bigs, it
made playing all those years worth it. He was one of the nicest guys I
ever met in the game and I was so proud that he was and will always be
my favorite player."
Thanks!