When I realized that the shortstop in Chris Gill's story was Austin Manahan, who had shared several great stories with my blog two years ago, I had to ask him for his memory of the incident. Here is his version of this great story:
"We were both playing second base that day - and this was the very
beginning of the season - I believe our first series of the year... And
yes, he charged a chopping ground ball and it drilled him right in the
mouth.
I remember that a few people were looking for the tooth for a while, but
we could not find it. Probably, the tooth came out of his mouth
covered in blood so when it hit the dirt it was instantly covered in
dirt and there was no way to see it. By the way, the field was not very
nice in Augusta and we actually wore mouth pieces for a while after
that game (I doubt Chris knows that).
Anyway, he was with the Charleston Wheelers and we were in the Southern division - Augusta
Pirates, we did not play them for a LONG TIME again.. it was the second
half, July sometime.. so a long time had passed. Now back to the
tooth.. It was a month or so after the incident that I found the tooth.
He had this correct,.. just after the national anthem I would look for
any rocks to grab off the field - more like a ritual, and I look down to
see this long white, shiny rock.. and I pick it up and sure enough,
there is the tooth - super long root. I put it in my locker and
purposely brought it up to West Virginia to give to him. If I remember
correctly, they won the Championship that year - and here is another tidbit.. Trevor Hoffman was the shortstop (Chris played 2nd that year) and
of course Trevor became an AMAZING pitcher and had a great career as a
closer. One last thing, at this same time, Pittsburgh had a minor
league infielder who also became an pitcher.. Tim Wakefield! What a
career he had as a pitcher."
Thanks! There is a card of Hoffman in the same set that I got my Chris Gill card.